close
close

MSU football grades vs. Ohio State: Offense, defense, coaching

MSU football grades vs. Ohio State: Offense, defense, coaching

play

Lansing State Journal columnist Graham Couch rates the Michigan State football team on a scale of 1 to 10 following its 38-7 home loss to Ohio State.

INJURY: 4

When you total 246 yards, turn in the red zone twice (three times total), and score just once, you'd think it was a completely dismal day offensively. But that's not the case. MSU managed to move the chains effectively in the first half, outscoring Ohio State on six plays of 15 yards or more. Aidan Chiles was the best he's ever been for a while, completing 10 of his first 12 throws – including the kind of deep out against Nick Marsh that will have you playing sometime on Sundays. But the attack continued in the second half and the mistakes in the first half prevented the result from being interesting.

DEFENSE: 5

During Ohio State's first offense, it seemed like it was going to be a long night for MSU's defense. But the Spartans used a penalty to force a field goal, then held on and made a couple of big stops when the outcome was still in doubt – an interception by Jordan Turner, whose return to the 12-yard line scored the only touchdown of the game MSU allowed , and a three-pointer after Chiles fumbled when the officiating team missed a blatant grab for his facemask. Emotions were running high in that moment and MSU's defense came through in a disciplined manner. The Spartans were beaten on third down too often, and when they did get a stop, they gave up a score or a first down on fourth down three times, although a touchdown came after an incredible catch by Ohio State freshman receiver Jeremiah Smith .

SPECIAL TEAMS: 4

Ryan Eckley averaged 46.6 yards on five punts, including a 58-yarder, but he made the one punt that really counted, a rare mistake for the MSU sophomore. Eckley's 27-yard punt late in the second quarter gave the Buckeyes a short field that turned into a touchdown drive just before halftime, giving them a 24-7 lead. That was the only notable special teams play all night.

RELATED: Couch: After the loss to Ohio State, the MSU football team should expect a lot from itself in Oregon

COACHING: 5

MSU’s offensive execution and early action were outstanding. The defense, banged up early, found its footing and made a few big plays and almost made a few more. The decision to go for it on fourth-and-1 on MSU's first drive can be questioned – I would have kicked the field goal – but was a sensible decision. The second half was uninspiring and for the first time MSU seemed to lose some of its will. The real test for this coaching staff this week will be getting a team that is licking its wounds to bounce back quickly and play as lively and resilient at Oregon as it did in the first half on Saturday.

CONCLUSION

Two defeats in a row. Neither unexpected nor. Nevertheless, it is adversity that will test the courage and cohesion of the MSU team. After the Oregon game, MSU gets a bye and a visit from Iowa 15 days beforehand. But this will be a difficult turn and a tough road trip. We will learn a lot about what this team consists of.

MORE: Couch: 3 quick reactions to Michigan State's 38-7 loss to Ohio State

Contact Graham Couch at [email protected]. Follow him on X @Graham_Couch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *